Nearly a decade after his historic 2016 victory, Donald J. Trump remains one of the most polarizing and influential political figures in American history. As the 2024 election cycle has passed and Trump continues to campaign, many are asking: would America still vote for him?
Within the Republican Party, the answer is largely yes. Despite mounting legal battles and a second impeachment, Trump’s grip on the GOP base remains firm. In most Republican primaries, Trump outperformed challengers by wide margins.
His loyal supporters—often referred to as the MAGA base—continue to rally around his populist message of “America First,” immigration reform, and a strong national identity.
National Polling Shows a Divided Nation
National polling, however, paints a more nuanced picture. Trump continues to command around 40–45% support in national surveys among likely voters—enough to be highly competitive in a general election, especially under the Electoral College system.
Recent polls from Gallup, Pew Research, and FiveThirtyEight suggest the electorate is split:
- Around 35% of Americans say they strongly support Trump.
- Another 15–20% are open to supporting him, depending on the Democratic candidate.
- Roughly 45% say they would never vote for him again under any circumstance.
These numbers reflect a nation deeply divided—not only on Trump himself, but on the direction of the country. Issues like inflation, immigration, crime, and freedom of speech continue to dominate voter concerns, and Trump’s messaging resonates strongly with many voters who feel left behind by the current administration.
Legal Troubles and Public Perception
Trump’s legal issues—ranging from the classified documents case to election interference investigations—have become a central part of the national conversation. Yet, for many of his supporters, these legal challenges are viewed not as disqualifying but as evidence of a political witch hunt.
According to an April 2025 Quinnipiac poll, 62% of Republican voters said they believe the charges against Trump are politically motivated. This sentiment has only strengthened his appeal among conservative and independent voters who distrust mainstream media and federal institutions.
However, for moderate and left-leaning voters, the legal cloud surrounding Trump remains a major concern. Some independents who supported him in 2016 but shifted in 2020 are hesitant to return to his camp in 2024, citing concerns over stability, democracy, and the January 6 Capitol riot.
The Biden Factor
President Joe Biden’s approval ratings have played a significant role in shaping Trump’s political comeback. As of early 2025, Biden’s approval sits in the low 40s, with key concerns around inflation, the southern border, and foreign policy shaping public sentiment.
If Biden remains the Democratic nominee, it sets up a potential rematch of the 2020 election. This dynamic could benefit Trump, especially if turnout among young or progressive voters lags due to dissatisfaction with Biden’s performance.
On the other hand, if Democrats nominate a younger or more charismatic candidate—like California Governor Gavin Newsom or Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer—it could complicate Trump’s path back to the White House by pulling in swing voters and independents.
Electoral College Still Favors Trump
Even if Trump loses the popular vote—as he did in 2016 and 2020—the Electoral College map may still work in his favor. His support remains strong in battleground states like:
- Florida
- Ohio
- North Carolina
- Iowa
- Wisconsin
- Arizona
In some cases, slight shifts of a few thousand votes in key counties could tip the balance. Political analysts continue to stress the importance of turnout and voter mobilization over national polling numbers.
A Referendum on America’s Future
Ultimately, whether America would still vote for Trump depends on how voters interpret the past four years. For some, Trump represents strength, economic growth, and a challenge to entrenched elites. For others, he symbolizes chaos, division, and authoritarian tendencies.
What’s clear is that Trump remains a major force in American politics. His rallies draw tens of thousands, his endorsements sway primaries, and his social media posts shape headlines. Love him or loathe him, Donald Trump is not fading from the spotlight anytime soon.
Conclusion
While Trump remains a top contender for the Republican nomination and a potential victor in the 2024 or even 2028 election, his fate ultimately lies in the hands of an electorate that remains deeply divided.
With legal challenges, political polarization, and a rapidly evolving voter base, the question of whether America would still vote for Trump doesn’t have a simple answer—but it’s one that will define the future of the country.
For more insights into Trump’s ongoing campaign and legal challenges, visit PBS NewsHour’s politics section.
Disclaimer – Our team has carefully fact-checked this article to make sure it’s accurate and free from any misinformation. We’re dedicated to keeping our content honest and reliable for our readers.