In a move sparking widespread criticism, the Social Security Administration (SSA), under direction from the Trump administration, has classified more than 6,000 legally residing immigrants as deceased. The decision effectively revoked their Social Security numbers (SSNs), disrupting lives, freezing access to employment, financial services, and government benefits.
The targeted immigrants, many of whom legally entered through programs created under the Biden administration, now face a bureaucratic nightmare and potential deportation.
The news was first reported by multiple outlets including CBS News, citing internal memos and confirmations from advocacy organizations. According to officials, the individuals were added to a renamed SSA database—once known as the “Death Master File,” now called the “Ineligible Master File”—with fabricated death dates.
This reclassification was done in coordination with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), which recently stripped these individuals of their temporary legal status.
False Declarations and Digital Death
The SSA’s action amounts to a kind of “digital death” for those affected. By listing someone as deceased in its records, the federal government invalidates their Social Security number. This makes it impossible to legally work, open bank accounts, access healthcare, receive benefits, or even maintain a place to live.
The reclassification occurred after DHS determined the legal entry of these individuals, many of whom used the CBP One app to enter the country, was no longer valid. Following this change in status, their names were submitted to SSA with instructions to mark them as deceased—a move widely seen as political and punitive.
Civil rights advocates say the administration’s intent is to compel these individuals to leave the country voluntarily—a policy known as “self-deportation.” The decision is reportedly part of a broader immigration crackdown planned should Trump return to office.
Outcry from Advocates and Lawmakers
The response from immigration advocates and Democratic lawmakers was swift and fierce. Nancy Altman, president of the advocacy group Social Security Works, condemned the action, stating: “This will not only create extreme hardship but kill people.
Imagine losing your income, health insurance, access to your bank account, your credit cards, your home—all because of a lie.”
Former SSA Commissioner Martin O’Malley, who served under the Biden administration, declared the action “illegal on so many scores.” He pointed to the SSA’s obligations under the law and stated that no rule allows the agency to declare someone dead unless there is verifiable proof of death. He warned that such misuse could erode public trust in vital institutions.
Immigration legal experts argue that the move violates due process protections, potentially opening the administration to lawsuits. “The Trump administration is weaponizing the Social Security Administration to target immigrants,” said Aaron Reichlin-Melnick of the American Immigration Council. “This is both morally and legally indefensible.”
Consequences for Immigrants and the Economy
For the immigrants caught in this legal trap, the consequences are devastating. In many cases, they are workers with clean records, tax-paying residents who believed they were following the law. Now, they are unable to prove their legal status or verify their identities because their SSNs have been rendered void.
Employers are also affected, unable to retain workers whose documentation now appears fraudulent. Financial institutions, which routinely check the SSA’s records to validate account holders, are reportedly freezing or closing bank accounts tied to the impacted SSNs.
The ripple effects are likely to extend beyond individual households. Economists warn that the sudden removal of thousands of people from the workforce could hinder productivity and complicate labor shortages in sectors such as agriculture, construction, and hospitality.
A Larger Agenda
The Trump campaign has not denied the policy, instead defending it as a way to discourage illegal immigration. White House spokesperson Elizabeth Huston said in a statement: “By removing the monetary incentive for illegal aliens to come and stay, we will encourage them to self-deport.”
Reports suggest that the administration is planning to expand the list significantly. One DHS memo leaked to the press outlines intentions to reclassify over 90,000 additional undocumented immigrants—primarily those with prior criminal convictions—as deceased in order to strip them of public services.
Lawmakers such as Representative John Larson, a senior member of the House Ways and Means Committee, have pledged to launch investigations into what he called “an outrageous abuse of power.” In a statement on his website, Larson added: “This action undermines the Social Security Administration and tears at the moral fabric of our nation.”
Potential Legal Repercussions
Legal organizations are preparing to challenge the policy in court. At the heart of the legal battle will be questions of due process, administrative authority, and human rights. Advocates argue that listing someone as dead without verifiable proof violates federal statutes and may even constitute identity theft.
Additionally, critics fear that this administrative tactic could be expanded beyond immigration policy. “If a government agency can falsely declare you dead for political reasons, there’s nothing stopping it from doing the same to dissidents, whistleblowers, or anyone it deems inconvenient,” warned legal analyst Susan Garcia on NPR.
Looking Ahead
The growing outrage over the SSA’s false declarations has sparked national debate about the limits of executive power, the role of federal agencies, and the future of immigration enforcement. As legal challenges move forward and congressional hearings loom, the affected immigrants remain in limbo—unable to work, access services, or live without fear.
What started as a bureaucratic maneuver may ultimately reshape how America treats its non-citizens, with implications for constitutional law, human rights, and civil liberties. Until then, the thousands of immigrants wrongly declared “dead” must fight to prove that they are, in fact, still alive.
For more information about Social Security records and eligibility, visit the U.S. Social Security Administration.
Disclaimer – Our team has carefully fact-checked this article to make sure it’s accurate and free from any misinformation. We’re dedicated to keeping our content honest and reliable for our readers.