A California man living with HIV was recently notified by the Social Security Administration (SSA) that he must repay more than $201,000 in Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) benefits.
The demand, which he describes as devastating, raises serious concerns over how benefit overpayments are handled — especially for vulnerable Americans dealing with chronic health conditions.
David McKinstry, a former social worker from Los Angeles, has been on disability for over a decade due to complications from HIV and related cognitive issues.
Yet despite regularly filing required income reports and tax documents, the SSA now claims he was overpaid for years. The sudden repayment demand has left McKinstry fearful for his future:
“I could be dead in a year or two. I’m sick. I don’t know what they expect me to do,” he said in an emotional interview with NBC News.
McKinstry’s case is one of thousands reported across the U.S. where individuals with disabilities are blindsided by large repayment notices — often through no fault of their own.
The Growing Crisis of Social Security Overpayment Notices
The SSA sends out tens of thousands of overpayment notices each year, amounting to billions of dollars. Many beneficiaries are elderly or disabled and often live below the poverty line.
These notices typically cite administrative errors, delayed income reporting, or incorrect earnings calculations as reasons for the overpayment.
According to a 2023 report from the SSA’s Office of Inspector General, the agency overpaid $21.6 billion over a five-year period, of which less than half has been recovered. While some overpayments are legitimate, others stem from internal bureaucratic delays or errors in data interpretation.
In McKinstry’s case, the SSA argues that he earned too much money while working part-time under a program that was supposed to help disability recipients transition back to work. He claims he was upfront about his income and filed the appropriate tax documents annually.
What to Do If You Receive an SSA Overpayment Letter
If the Social Security Administration sends you a notice demanding repayment of disability or retirement benefits, it’s important to act quickly. Here are the immediate steps you should take:
1. Do Not Ignore the Letter
Ignoring the overpayment notice can result in immediate reductions to your monthly benefits or garnishment of wages. Read the notice carefully and take note of deadlines.
2. Request a Waiver
You can apply for a waiver if you believe the overpayment was not your fault and if repaying it would cause you financial hardship. You will need to file Form SSA-632 and submit proof of income, expenses, and assets.
3. File an Appeal
If you disagree with the SSA’s determination, you can file a Request for Reconsideration (Form SSA-561) within 60 days. Be prepared to provide supporting documentation showing your compliance and reporting.
4. Get Legal Assistance
Organizations such as the National Organization of Social Security Claimants’ Representatives (NOSSCR) or your local legal aid office may offer free or low-cost legal help.
5. Contact Your Representative
Congressional offices can intervene on behalf of constituents in Social Security cases. Reach out to your U.S. senator or House representative for assistance.
Lawmakers and Advocates Push for Reform
McKinstry’s story has drawn the attention of disability rights advocates and lawmakers alike. Critics argue that the SSA’s repayment process lacks transparency and disproportionately affects low-income individuals. Many have called for reforms that would limit how far back the agency can retroactively claim overpayments and expand hardship exemptions.
U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown (D-OH), who chairs the Senate Finance Committee’s subcommittee on Social Security, has introduced legislation to create a more compassionate and error-proof system:
“We cannot allow bureaucratic errors to destroy people’s lives. We need a fair and humane appeals process,” Brown stated during a recent hearing.
Additionally, the SSA has announced that it is currently reviewing its overpayment procedures and may implement new policies to reduce future mistakes and offer more flexible repayment plans.
Conclusion: Don’t Panic, Know Your Rights
Cases like David McKinstry’s highlight the urgent need for reform within the Social Security Administration, particularly around how overpayments are identified and handled.
While the prospect of a six-figure repayment may seem overwhelming, disabled Americans have options — and rights — that can help them fight back.
Whether you’re dealing with SSDI, SSI, or retirement benefit issues, it’s crucial to act promptly, gather your documentation, and seek support. With advocacy, legal guidance, and proposed legislative changes on the horizon, there’s hope for a more compassionate system in the future.
For more on how to respond to Social Security overpayment notices, visit the Social Security Administration’s Overpayments page.
Disclaimer – Our team has carefully fact-checked this article to make sure it’s accurate and free from any misinformation. We’re dedicated to keeping our content honest and reliable for our readers.