WASHINGTON, D.C. — Millions of older Americans with defaulted federal student loans could soon see a significant reduction in their monthly Social Security payments.
As the U.S. Department of Education resumes debt collections following a pandemic-era pause, advocates warn that benefits could be slashed to as low as $750 per month, raising new alarms about retirement security and elder poverty.
This renewed collection effort follows the expiration of a COVID-era suspension that shielded many seniors from garnishment.
Now, as federal recovery programs ramp back up, the government is preparing to garnish a portion of Social Security benefits from borrowers who have defaulted on federal student loans — a practice that has long been controversial but is legally permitted under current law.
How Garnishment of Social Security Works
Under federal law, the government may withhold up to 15% of a borrower’s Social Security check to recover defaulted federal student loan debt. However, current protections mandate that monthly benefits cannot be reduced below $750 — a figure that has not been adjusted since 1998.
For example, a senior receiving $1,100 in monthly benefits could see roughly $165 garnished, leaving them with only $935 to cover basic needs. Those receiving slightly higher benefits could be left with just $750 after garnishment, a threshold many say is insufficient in today’s economy.
For official policy details, visit the Social Security Administration’s page on benefit withholding.
Resumption of Debt Collection
The federal government paused most student loan payments and collections in March 2020 as part of pandemic relief measures. That included halting involuntary collections, such as garnishing wages or Social Security benefits.
But that pause ended in October 2023, and collection efforts are gradually resuming throughout 2024.
The Department of Education has confirmed that borrowers who remain in default could now be subject to garnishments again, including those who receive Social Security as their primary or only income.
According to the Government Accountability Office (GAO), over 114,000 Americans age 62 and older had their benefits garnished for student loan debt in 2015 alone — a number expected to rise as collections resume.
Who’s Most at Risk?
Many seniors with defaulted loans either took out debt for their own education decades ago or co-signed or borrowed on behalf of children or grandchildren through Parent PLUS loans. With rising tuition costs and limited income in retirement, these borrowers are especially vulnerable.
According to a report from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), older borrowers are the fastest-growing group with student loan debt, with over 3.5 million Americans aged 60 and up holding student loans in 2023. Roughly 40% of those borrowers are in default.
“It’s a cruel irony that seniors who worked their entire lives, and in many cases borrowed to help family members attend college, are now being punished in retirement,” said Persis Yu, managing counsel at the Student Borrower Protection Center.
Biden Administration’s Limited Relief Measures
In response to growing pressure, the Biden administration has attempted to implement relief options for struggling borrowers. This includes initiatives like the Fresh Start program, which allows defaulted borrowers to reenter good standing, avoid garnishment, and enroll in affordable repayment plans.
However, the program requires proactive enrollment, and many older borrowers may not be aware of the option or know how to navigate the process. As a result, those who do not take action could see their benefits reduced.
To learn more or enroll in Fresh Start, visit the Federal Student Aid site.
Advocates Call for Higher Protections
Advocates argue that the $750 threshold is grossly outdated and does not reflect the current cost of living. The National Consumer Law Center (NCLC) has called on Congress to update the protected amount to reflect inflation and prevent seniors from falling into poverty.
“The idea that someone can survive on $750 a month is unrealistic,” said Abby Shafroth, director of NCLC’s student loan borrower assistance project. “This is a policy stuck in the past, punishing the elderly for loans that often weren’t their own.”
Many lawmakers have echoed those concerns. Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR) introduced legislation last year that would raise the protected amount and restrict garnishment of Social Security for student loan debt entirely. But the bill has stalled in Congress.
Financial Impact on Retirees
With inflation continuing to drive up the cost of essentials like rent, food, and healthcare, a reduction in monthly Social Security payments could have serious consequences for seniors already living on the edge.
Data from the Social Security Administration shows that nearly half of all retirees rely on their monthly benefits for 90% or more of their income. Any garnishment — particularly one that lowers their income to the $750 threshold — could result in housing instability, food insecurity, and health risks.
“The effects are not just financial — they’re physical and emotional,” said Maria Alvarez, executive director of StateWide Senior Action. “Seniors who worked their whole lives should not be faced with this indignity.”
What Borrowers Can Do Now
Experts urge affected borrowers to act quickly:
- Check default status at studentaid.gov
- Apply for Fresh Start to restore federal loan eligibility
- Contact a loan servicer to explore income-driven repayment plans
- Seek free counseling from nonprofit financial advisors or local legal aid
Additionally, those who believe garnishment has been applied in error can appeal the action or request a hardship exemption through the Department of Education.
Conclusion: A Call for Legislative Action
As the federal government resumes debt collection, thousands of seniors are poised to face steep cuts to their Social Security checks. Without legislative reform or increased awareness of available relief programs, the most vulnerable retirees may be left with only $750 a month — an amount many say is simply not enough to survive.
With collections resuming and economic pressures mounting, borrowers and advocates are calling on lawmakers to act swiftly to protect retirement security.
To contact your elected officials or learn more about pending legislation, visit USA.gov’s elected officials directory.
Disclaimer – Our team has carefully fact-checked this article to make sure it’s accurate and free from any misinformation. We’re dedicated to keeping our content honest and reliable for our readers.