Former President Donald Trump is pushing back after podcast host Joe Rogan issued a stark warning that mass deportation policies could turn Americans into “monsters.”
During a recent episode of The Joe Rogan Experience, the influential media personality voiced concerns about the human cost of deporting millions of undocumented immigrants, arguing that aggressive removals could dehumanize the public and law enforcement alike.
Rogan’s comments quickly gained traction online, prompting a pointed response from Trump, who dismissed the criticism and doubled down on his immigration agenda as necessary for restoring law and order.
Trump has made large-scale deportations a centerpiece of his 2024 campaign platform, promising to launch the “largest domestic deportation operation in American history” if reelected.
What Joe Rogan Said About Deportations
During a recent interview with comedian Andrew Schulz, Joe Rogan expressed deep reservations about Trump’s proposed immigration crackdown. While acknowledging the complexity of the issue, Rogan warned that forcibly removing millions of undocumented immigrants could fundamentally alter the moral fabric of the country.
“You don’t want to become a monster,” Rogan said. “It’s very easy to become a monster when you’re rounding up millions of people and kicking them out of the country. That’s how you lose your soul.”
The comment sparked widespread debate on social media, where some praised Rogan for highlighting the ethical implications of immigration enforcement, while others criticized him for underestimating the scale of illegal immigration and its effects on American communities.
Trump Responds: “We’re Not Monsters — We’re Patriots”
Trump swiftly responded to Rogan’s comments during a campaign rally in Michigan, where he defended his immigration policies as both humane and necessary.
“We’re not monsters — we’re patriots,” Trump said to applause. “We are going to protect our borders, our workers, and our country. Joe Rogan doesn’t understand what’s happening in our cities, our schools, and our hospitals because of illegal immigration.”
The former president also emphasized that his deportation strategy would prioritize criminal offenders and national security threats, though his broader plan includes mass removals of undocumented immigrants who entered the country illegally, regardless of their criminal record.
“We’re going to do it legally, but we’re going to do it strongly,” Trump added.
Immigration Policy at the Heart of 2024 Campaign
Immigration has become one of the most polarizing issues heading into the 2024 presidential election. Trump’s pledge to resume large-scale deportations has energized his base, but it has also raised concerns among moderates and civil rights groups.
According to The New York Times, Trump’s plan includes reinstating Title 42-style expulsions, expanding detention centers, and deploying the National Guard to assist with immigration enforcement.
Joe Biden’s administration, by contrast, has focused on creating legal pathways to citizenship while implementing targeted border enforcement. Critics say Biden’s policies are too lenient, while advocates argue they are more humane and sustainable.
Rogan, who has previously interviewed both left- and right-leaning guests, stopped short of endorsing either approach outright. Still, his remarks struck a chord with listeners who fear that mass deportations could lead to abuses of power and human rights violations.
Experts Weigh In on the Debate
Immigration experts are divided on the feasibility and morality of Trump’s proposed deportation operation. Some warn that such an initiative could require massive government overreach, including the expansion of federal enforcement powers and billions in new funding.
“Mass deportations on the scale Trump is describing would require a militarized response and the suspension of due process rights for millions of people,” said Cecilia Muñoz, former director of the White House Domestic Policy Council under President Obama.
“That’s what Joe Rogan is warning about — the psychological and constitutional risks.”
Others argue that failing to enforce immigration laws erodes the rule of law and places undue strain on local services, particularly in border states and sanctuary cities.
“There’s nothing monstrous about enforcing immigration law,” said Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies. “We are a nation of laws, and if we don’t enforce those laws, we cease to be a functioning republic.”
A Cultural Divide Over Immigration
The back-and-forth between Trump and Rogan highlights a broader cultural divide over immigration in America.
While many conservatives view mass deportations as essential to national sovereignty, critics warn of the moral compromises and long-term social consequences such policies may carry.
Joe Rogan’s comments reflect a growing segment of the population—especially independents and younger voters—who may support secure borders but balk at what they perceive as draconian tactics.
Trump’s uncompromising stance, meanwhile, continues to appeal to voters frustrated by years of perceived inaction on immigration.
As the 2024 election nears, the clash over deportation policy could become a defining issue—not only for Trump and Biden but for the moral identity of the nation itself.
For further insights into Trump’s immigration platform and public reaction, visit The New York Times coverage of his deportation plan.
Disclaimer – Our team has carefully fact-checked this article to make sure it’s accurate and free from any misinformation. We’re dedicated to keeping our content honest and reliable for our readers.